Laura M. Casamento, Ed.D., Nicole C. Woodall, CPA

NEW BERLIN – Preferred Mutual Insurance Company is proud to announce the appointments of Laura M. Casamento, Ed.D., and Nicole C. Woodall, CPA, to its Board of Directors. Both bring over 25 years of experience in their respective fields and will serve on key board committees, contributing to the company’s strategic objectives.

Casamento most recently served as President and Chief Executive Officer of Utica University, where she led initiatives that enhanced the institution’s reputation, improved student success, and achieved university status. She also spearheaded fundraising efforts and expanded local workforce development opportunities. Additionally, she has experience in the financial sector, having served as President and COO of Herkimer County Trust, where she guided the bank through a period of growth and played a key role in its eventual sale. With her leadership experience across corporate and higher education sectors, Casamento is a valuable addition to the board’s Compensation and Benefits Committee.

Woodall, a Certified Public Accountant, brings deep expertise in tax accounting, consulting, and compliance services. As a partner at Citrin Cooperman and previously a Tax Partner at Baker Tilly US, LLP, she has advised Fortune 500 and Fortune 1000 companies on tax strategies and compliance. Woodall has led multi-state and federal income tax projects, managed complex tax audits, and driven innovative solutions for clients across various industries. She will be a key member of the board’s Audit and Risk Committee.


“We’re excited to welcome both Laura Casamento and Nicole Woodall to our board,” said John C. Mitchell, Chairman of the Board of Directors at Preferred Mutual Insurance Company. “Their expertise in leadership, finance, and strategy will be instrumental as we continue to pursue our mission and serve our policyholders and communities.”


Preferred Mutual Insurance Company provides property and casualty insurance coverage to more than 232,000 individual and business customers through a network of more than 560 independent agents located throughout New York, New Jersey, Massachusetts, and New Hampshire. In business since 1896, Preferred Mutual is rated “A” by AM Best Company and is headquartered in New Berlin, New York. Learn more at www.preferredmutual.com.